If you haven’t been to the Colts Neck Inn Steakhouse lately, it’s time to grab your favorite people and make the trip. This iconic spot in Colts Neck, New Jersey, has been serving up history and hospitality since 1717, and now, after some exciting renovations, it’s better than ever.
The History
Let’s start with the history because it’s pretty incredible. The Colts Neck Inn is the oldest inn in New Jersey and one of the oldest in the entire country. Think about that—this place has been around for over 300 years! Owned by the Mavrookas family, they’ve poured their heart and soul into keeping the charm alive while also giving the place a fresh, modern feel. It’s a place where you can really feel the blend of past and present.
Party Time
One of the highlights of the recent revamp is the banquet facility. If you’re planning a special event—a wedding, a birthday, an engagement party, or even a corporate gathering—this is the spot to do it. The space is elegant, flexible, and perfect for making those big moments extra memorable. Plus, the team is fantastic at customizing menus and making sure everything runs smoothly.
The Food
Speaking of menus, let’s talk about the food because the menu has had a major revamp, too. Their hand-cut steaks are legendary—some say they’re the best in Monmouth County and beyond. If you’re a steak lover, the Filet Mignon is a must-try, served with garlic mashed potatoes, grilled asparagus, and a rich cabernet demi-glace. But it’s not just about the steaks.
If you’re craving a top-tier burger, the CNI Cheese Burger is a must-try. This 8 oz. Certified USDA Beef Burger is cooked to juicy perfection and stacked with melted cheddar cheese, caramelized onions, crisp lettuce, and fresh tomato on a soft brioche bun. But what really takes it to the next level? The CNI Secret Sauce—a mouthwatering, flavorful touch that keeps you coming back for more. Served with a generous side of hand-cut fries, this burger is a perfect blend of classic comfort and steakhouse quality.
And here’s a fun twist: they’ve added a sushi program to the menu. Yes, sushi! Try the Tuna Maki Roll or the colorful Rainbow Salmon & Tuna Roll if you’re in the mood for something fresh and different.
The Drinks
Of course, no great meal is complete without a great drink. The Colts Neck Inn’s bar is stocked with all your favorites, but their specialty martinis really steal the show. The Raspberry Lychee Martini and Lavender Lemondrop are just two highlights—they’re as delicious as they are Instagram-worthy.
The Vibe
The Colts Neck Inn Steakhouse offers a dining experience that perfectly balances history, comfort, and style. The large bar area is a lively and inviting space with ample seating. Surrounding the bar, cozy booths provide the perfect spot for casual dining, whether you’re grabbing a burger with friends or enjoying a laid-back night out. Every weekend, they host live music that turns a great dinner into an unforgettable night out.
If you’re looking for something more intimate, the formal dining room sets the stage for a refined yet welcoming experience. The romantic lighting creates a warm, elegant ambiance, while the etched glass artwork depicting horse racing pays homage to Colts Neck’s rich equestrian heritage.
The Colts Neck Inn Steakhouse isn’t just a restaurant. It’s a piece of New Jersey history, a place to celebrate life’s milestones, and a spot where incredible food and good times come together. Whether you’re stopping by for a casual dinner, planning a big event, or just want to soak up the atmosphere with some live music and a cocktail, you’ll leave feeling like part of the family.
“The Colts Neck Inn isn’t just a restaurant to me—it’s my family’s legacy. My grandfather bought it in 1973, and it’s been passed down through the generations. After years away, I’m back to help revitalize it and bring it back to its rightful place as a Monmouth County staple. This isn’t just about business—it’s about honoring my family’s history and building a future for the next generation.” offered George Mavrookas, whose father, Lou, is the owner and operator.
So, what are you waiting for? The Colts Neck Inn Steakhouse is back and better than ever. Reserve your table and see for yourself why this historic gem is still one of the best spots around.
The Colts Neck Inn Steakhouse
191 County Road 537 W
Colts Neck, NJ 07722
Website
Follow the link for more restaurant spotlights.