Locale has found its place in Little Silver. Now, the team behind the popular Italian restaurant has expanded its footprint, literally right across the parking lot.

Interior of Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver, NJ, featuring pizza display counters, wood floors, casual seating, and a Livoti’s specialty market section.
A look inside the new Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver, where fresh pizza, prepared foods, casual seating, and a Livoti’s Old World Market section come together under one roof.

The newly opened Locale Pizzeria combines a pizzeria, café, and market, giving the restaurant’s growing pizza and takeout business its own space.

Freshly made New York-style pizzas displayed by the slice at Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver, NJ.
Pizza by the slice or whole pie? Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver serves New York-style pizza with a thin, crispy crust, available for dine-in or takeout.

“Both sides of the business have outgrown each other,” says Locale General Manager Ryan Thibault. “We’ve had so much great success within the restaurant that it’s time to really let people know what our pizza and takeout side can offer.”

From North Jersey to Little Silver

Original Locale Italian restaurant in Little Silver, NJ, located across the parking lot from the new Locale Pizzeria & Market.
The original Locale Restaurant in Little Silver, where the success of its Italian dining and takeout business led to the opening of Locale Pizzeria & Market across the parking lot.

Brothers Giuseppe (Joey) and Tommaso (Tommy) Ottaiano brought a family history in restaurants to Locale. Their father owns a longtime restaurant in Livingston, where Joey learned the business firsthand.

Tommy, who had settled near Red Bank, connected with Matt Kelly of Kelly Builders in an unlikely setting: a sauna. A conversation about opening a restaurant eventually became Locale.

For general manager Ryan Thibault, who has known Tommy since sixth grade, Little Silver felt like home.

“Little Silver is special,” he says. “It’s got that small-town feel, and we grew up with that small-town feel in North Jersey. So it hits home to us.”

As Locale’s dine-in and takeout business grew, the team saw an opportunity to give its pizza operation a space of its own.

A New Home for Locale Pizza

Freshly baked pizzas in the display case at Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver, NJ, with a pizza maker removing a pie from the oven.
Fresh from the oven! At Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver, New York-style pizzas are made on-site and available by the slice or whole pie.

The new pizzeria offers a different experience from the original restaurant, where Locale serves Neapolitan-style pizza with a softer, doughier crust. The pizzeria focuses on thinner, New York-style pizza, along with a broader selection of prepared foods and market offerings.

Assortment of Italian desserts on display at Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver, NJ.
Save room for dessert! Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver offers a tempting selection of sweets alongside its pizzas, sandwiches, salads, and prepared foods.

The expansion also lets the original restaurant and the new pizzeria develop their own identities while staying just steps apart.

Locale Meets Livoti’s

Livoti’s Old World Market section inside Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver, NJ, featuring Italian specialty market offerings.
Locale’s partnership with Livoti’s Old World Market comes full circle with a dedicated market section inside the new Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver.

Locale’s pizza business has also expanded beyond Little Silver through a partnership with Livoti’s Old World Market.

The relationship began through an existing connection with Tommy and eventually led to Locale taking over pizza operations at Livoti’s Brick, Middletown, and Freehold stores.

This isn’t simply a licensing arrangement. Locale supplies its own products, delivers ingredients regularly, and staffs the pizza counters with employees trained by its pizza team.

Locale pizza counter inside Livoti’s Old World Market in New Jersey, where Locale operates the market’s pizza program.
Locale brings its New York-style pizza to Livoti’s Old World Market, operating the pizza counters at the Brick, Middletown, and Freehold locations.

“Every single guy that works in there is one of my guys, trained by my pizza guy,” Ryan says. “Every product is our product.”

The partnership introduces Locale to customers throughout Monmouth and Ocean counties, while Livoti’s is also participating in the new Little Silver pizzeria and market concept.

Ryan describes the relationship as “just the beginning,” hinting at additional plans that have yet to be announced.

A Taste of the New Locale Pizzeria

We got an early taste of what the new pizzeria has to offer, and there’s much more on the menu than pizza.

Our sampling included Eggplant Caprese, Balsamic Wings, Cacio e Pepe, Shrimp Arrabbiata, and a Mediterranean Salad. We also tried the Crispy Thin Grilled Chicken Broccoli Pizza, showcasing the thinner crust that distinguishes the pizzeria’s pies from those served in Locale’s dining room.

And then there was the Chicken Parm Sandwich, bringing one of Locale’s signature dishes to the takeout menu.

Chicken parm is something the team takes seriously. Locale has won back-to-back chicken parm competitions hosted by The Tipsy Critic.

“Chicken parm is something we don’t play around with,” Ryan says.

All seven dishes we sampled are featured on the new menu, giving customers plenty of options for a quick lunch, casual dinner, or takeout meal.

Pizza maker preparing fresh New York-style pizza at Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver, NJ.
Pizza making in action at Locale Pizzeria & Market in Little Silver, where New York-style pies are made fresh and served by the slice or as a whole pie.

For the Locale team, the new pizzeria is another chapter in the restaurant’s success story. And judging by their enthusiasm, they’re far from finished.

Locale Pizzeria and Market
24 Ayers Lane, Little Silver, NJ 07739

Planning your next night out? Explore our Best Restaurants in New Jersey guide for more dining inspiration.