Home > Burgers > Jersey Shore Restaurant Week’s Great Burger Contest Results!

Jersey Shore Restaurant Week’s Great Burger Contest Results!


Jersey Shore Restaurant Week Burger Contest, Deborah Smith, Great Jersey Shore Burger Contest, Burgers, Jersey Bites

It was a beautiful day for some burgers and beer at Saturday’s Great Jersey Shore Burger Contest. While the contestants were toiling away at their grills on the deck of Bar Anticipation, in Lake Como, the judges huddled in the dark dining room with our scoresheets and loads of napkins at the ready.

Deborah Smith, Great Jersey Shore Burger Contest, Burgers, Jersey Bites

Burger Contest

The burger contest is a blind competition, meaning we do not know which restaurant is linked to each burger submission.

The first criteria for the judges is how well the burger is cooked. Not well done—please never—but we do consider whether the burger is a perfect medium—medium rare, or is it too rare, or overcooked? All contestants hit the right mark with no problem.

This year we saw a few all-beef patties, a couple of short-rib/brisket blends, and even a chorizo dry-aged burger blend. No lamb burgers or anything far away from beef as in years past. Onions seemed to be a big trend this year. Onion rolls, sauteed onions, frizzled onions, and onion jam all found their way into and on top of many of the burger. And who can blame them? They’re the perfect combination. Toppings ranged from the expected, like bacon and cheddar cheese, to the unexpected papitas and Manchego.

St. Stephens' Greene, People's Choice Winner, Deborah Smith, Great Jersey Shore Burger Contest, Burgers, Jersey Bites

St. Stephens’ Greene: People’s Choice

Craft Beer Fest

We were pleasantly surprised to see that the breweries in attendance were all from New Jersey. Some relative newcomers like Last Wave Brewing and ManaFirkin were there as well as some old favorites like Carton Brewing, Ship Bottom Brewery and Asbury Park Brewery. Frye Brewing from Point Pleasant Boro served up a very impressive Maibock. ManaFirkin poured an impressive New England style IPA appropriately named Bang a Wicked ‘Uey and Last Wave poured every last drop of its popular A-Frame IPA. An all-Jersey beer lineup might just become a staple for this event.

New Jersey Craft Beer Jersey Shore Restaurant Week, Deborah Smith, Great Jersey Shore Burger Contest, Burgers, Jersey Bites

Exclusively NJ craft beer at the Great Jersey Shore Burger Contest

Burger 25 from Toms River, Judges' Choice, Deborah Smith, Great Jersey Shore Burger Contest, Burgers, Jersey Bites

Burger 25 from Toms River: Judges’ Choice

Winners!

And the winners are…

Burger 25 in Toms River for its Frisky Whiskey burger. The winning burger was made of angus beef topped with Jack Daniels caramelized onions, provolone cheese, house-made Jack Daniels sauce, crispy onion straws, and Applewood smoked bacon on a fresh baked onion bun.

Deborah Smith, Great Jersey Shore Burger Contest, Burgers, Jersey Bites

St. Stephen’s Green Publick House won the People’s Choice Award for the Trinity Onion burger.

St. Stephen's Green Publick House won People's Choice, Deborah Smith, Great Jersey Shore Burger Contest, Burgers, Jersey Bites

St. Stephen’s Green Publick House: People’s Choice

St. Stephen’s used a filet and hanger steak blend topped with homemade onion bacon jam, charred Gruyére, and frizzled onions served on an onion brioche bun.

Some of the other standouts in the competition were B2 Bistro Pt. Beach’s Frita Burger which gave a nod to the Chef’s time spent working in Miami and started with a blend of Chorizo and dry-aged burger and topped with papitas, Manchego, special sauce, and caramelized onions.

Bar Anticipation burger, Deborah Smith, Great Jersey Shore Burger Contest, Burgers, Jersey Bites

Bar Anticipation’s Sweet & Spicy Short Rib Burger should have won for best dressed as far as I was concerned and was a very tasty burger in its own right. This one was a short-rib, brisket-blend burger topped with fresh mango salsa, caramelized onions, pepper jack cheese, sweet and salty soy glaze, and sriracha mayo.

You may also like
Jersey Shore Restaurant Week 2019
Jersey Shore Restaurant Week: April 5-14, 2019
Now Introducing DJ Joe and Nicky D: Two Jersey Boys with a Podcast
Wholefoods Metuchen exterior
Whole Foods Opens in Metuchen
Recipe: Spicy Corn with Peppadew Peppers and Avocado Mayo